Friday, October 22, 2010
Tuesday, September 8, 2009
Why writing poetry is like fighting a duel
Poetry must combine thought and writing for it to be any good. If it is only thought, no one but the poet and perhaps someone he speaks it to gets to enjoy it. So a poem must be written to be widely enjoyed. But writing imposes a foreign structure on a poem; it slows the poem down immensely and subjects it to structure. The flow of poetic thought is encumbered by the bulky responsibility to actually write or type the words, to format them, to make them fit in an orderly way. The key to good poetry is to think like you weren't writing and write like you weren't thinking: to achieve the levity and brightness of thought together with the gravity and impact of written word. Good poetry always delivers a sense of spontaneous thought and calculated word.
This is obvious in the nature of the two communications and combining them is so hard because they are mutually resistant. The grip of brilliant conversation lies largely in its spontaneity; a brilliant joke in the moment is hardly funny a moment later when it is obvious it has been calculated. Likewise a stunning retort. The amusing or enchanting quality of expressions, mannerisms, and syntax in casual conversation come from their spontaneity. This is why acting requires so much talent. But written word, conversely, owes its primary qualities to the fact that it is not spontaneous. It is calculated, deliberate, and precise. The brilliance of the written word is not so much that an author could think up this or that idea - although some original ideas are so brilliant that they are unbelievable even in the written word - but in the effect of its deliberate designs.
And thus poetry is so hard to write. One person could write a hundred volumes of prose or say a thousand clever phrases, but to be Shakespeare you must almost be a god.
Corollary: when you have a thought for a poem, drop everything and start writing. Even if you're holding a baby.
This is obvious in the nature of the two communications and combining them is so hard because they are mutually resistant. The grip of brilliant conversation lies largely in its spontaneity; a brilliant joke in the moment is hardly funny a moment later when it is obvious it has been calculated. Likewise a stunning retort. The amusing or enchanting quality of expressions, mannerisms, and syntax in casual conversation come from their spontaneity. This is why acting requires so much talent. But written word, conversely, owes its primary qualities to the fact that it is not spontaneous. It is calculated, deliberate, and precise. The brilliance of the written word is not so much that an author could think up this or that idea - although some original ideas are so brilliant that they are unbelievable even in the written word - but in the effect of its deliberate designs.
And thus poetry is so hard to write. One person could write a hundred volumes of prose or say a thousand clever phrases, but to be Shakespeare you must almost be a god.
Corollary: when you have a thought for a poem, drop everything and start writing. Even if you're holding a baby.
Wednesday, August 26, 2009
Piper's Blog Post
Perhaps you already ran across this article; I'd be interested to hear your thoughts.
The Tornado, the Lutherans, and Homosexuality
August 20, 2009 | By: John Piper | Category: Commentary
I saw the fast-moving, misshapen, unusually-wide funnel over downtown Minneapolis from Seven Corners. I said to Kevin Dau, “That looks serious.”
It was. Serious in more ways than one. A friend who drove down to see the damage wrote,
On a day when no severe weather was predicted or expected...a tornado forms, baffling the weather experts—most saying they’ve never seen anything like it. It happens right in the city. The city: Minneapolis.
The tornado happens on a Wednesday...during the Evangelical Lutheran Church of America's national convention in the Minneapolis Convention Center. The convention is using Central Lutheran across the street as its church. The church has set up tents around it’s building for this purpose.
According to the ELCA’s printed convention schedule, at 2 PM on Wednesday, August 19, the 5th session of the convention was to begin. The main item of the session: “Consideration: Proposed Social Statement on Human Sexuality.” The issue is whether practicing homosexuality is a behavior that should disqualify a person from the pastoral ministry.
The eyewitness of the damage continues:
This curious tornado touches down just south of downtown and follows 35W straight towards the city center. It crosses I94. It is now downtown.
The time: 2PM.
The first buildings on the downtown side of I94 are the Minneapolis Convention Center and Central Lutheran. The tornado severely damages the convention center roof, shreds the tents, breaks off the steeple of Central Lutheran, splits what’s left of the steeple in two...and then lifts.
Central Lutheran's broken steeple
Let me venture an interpretation of this Providence with some biblical warrant.
1. The unrepentant practice of homosexual behavior (like other sins) will exclude a person from the kingdom of God.
The unrighteous will not inherit the kingdom of God? Do not be deceived: neither the sexually immoral, nor idolaters, nor adulterers, nor men who practice homosexuality, nor thieves, nor the greedy, nor drunkards, nor revilers, nor swindlers will inherit the kingdom of God.” (1 Corinthians 6:9-10)
2. The church has always embraced those who forsake sexual sin but who still struggle with homosexual desires, rejoicing with them that all our fallen, sinful, disordered lives (all of us, no exceptions) are forgiven if we turn to Christ in faith.
Such were some of you. But you were washed, you were sanctified, you were justified in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ and by the Spirit of our God. (1 Corinthians 6:11)
3. Therefore, official church pronouncements that condone the very sins that keep people out of the kingdom of God, are evil. They dishonor God, contradict Scripture, and implicitly promote damnation where salvation is freely offered.
4. Jesus Christ controls the wind, including all tornados.
Who then is this, that even the wind and the sea obey him? (Mark 4:41)
5. When asked about a seemingly random calamity near Jerusalem where 18 people were killed, Jesus answered in general terms—an answer that would cover calamities in Minneapolis, Taiwan, or Baghdad. God’s message is repent, because none of us will otherwise escape God’s judgment.
Jesus: “Those eighteen on whom the tower in Siloam fell and killed them: do you think that they were worse offenders than all the others who lived in Jerusalem? No, I tell you; but unless you repent, you will all likewise perish.” (Luke 13:4-5)
6. Conclusion: The tornado in Minneapolis was a gentle but firm warning to the ELCA and all of us: Turn from the approval of sin. Turn from the promotion of behaviors that lead to destruction. Reaffirm the great Lutheran heritage of allegiance to the truth and authority of Scripture. Turn back from distorting the grace of God into sensuality. Rejoice in the pardon of the cross of Christ and its power to transform left and right wing sinners.
The Tornado, the Lutherans, and Homosexuality
August 20, 2009 | By: John Piper | Category: Commentary
I saw the fast-moving, misshapen, unusually-wide funnel over downtown Minneapolis from Seven Corners. I said to Kevin Dau, “That looks serious.”
It was. Serious in more ways than one. A friend who drove down to see the damage wrote,
On a day when no severe weather was predicted or expected...a tornado forms, baffling the weather experts—most saying they’ve never seen anything like it. It happens right in the city. The city: Minneapolis.
The tornado happens on a Wednesday...during the Evangelical Lutheran Church of America's national convention in the Minneapolis Convention Center. The convention is using Central Lutheran across the street as its church. The church has set up tents around it’s building for this purpose.
According to the ELCA’s printed convention schedule, at 2 PM on Wednesday, August 19, the 5th session of the convention was to begin. The main item of the session: “Consideration: Proposed Social Statement on Human Sexuality.” The issue is whether practicing homosexuality is a behavior that should disqualify a person from the pastoral ministry.
The eyewitness of the damage continues:
This curious tornado touches down just south of downtown and follows 35W straight towards the city center. It crosses I94. It is now downtown.
The time: 2PM.
The first buildings on the downtown side of I94 are the Minneapolis Convention Center and Central Lutheran. The tornado severely damages the convention center roof, shreds the tents, breaks off the steeple of Central Lutheran, splits what’s left of the steeple in two...and then lifts.
Central Lutheran's broken steeple
Let me venture an interpretation of this Providence with some biblical warrant.
1. The unrepentant practice of homosexual behavior (like other sins) will exclude a person from the kingdom of God.
The unrighteous will not inherit the kingdom of God? Do not be deceived: neither the sexually immoral, nor idolaters, nor adulterers, nor men who practice homosexuality, nor thieves, nor the greedy, nor drunkards, nor revilers, nor swindlers will inherit the kingdom of God.” (1 Corinthians 6:9-10)
2. The church has always embraced those who forsake sexual sin but who still struggle with homosexual desires, rejoicing with them that all our fallen, sinful, disordered lives (all of us, no exceptions) are forgiven if we turn to Christ in faith.
Such were some of you. But you were washed, you were sanctified, you were justified in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ and by the Spirit of our God. (1 Corinthians 6:11)
3. Therefore, official church pronouncements that condone the very sins that keep people out of the kingdom of God, are evil. They dishonor God, contradict Scripture, and implicitly promote damnation where salvation is freely offered.
4. Jesus Christ controls the wind, including all tornados.
Who then is this, that even the wind and the sea obey him? (Mark 4:41)
5. When asked about a seemingly random calamity near Jerusalem where 18 people were killed, Jesus answered in general terms—an answer that would cover calamities in Minneapolis, Taiwan, or Baghdad. God’s message is repent, because none of us will otherwise escape God’s judgment.
Jesus: “Those eighteen on whom the tower in Siloam fell and killed them: do you think that they were worse offenders than all the others who lived in Jerusalem? No, I tell you; but unless you repent, you will all likewise perish.” (Luke 13:4-5)
6. Conclusion: The tornado in Minneapolis was a gentle but firm warning to the ELCA and all of us: Turn from the approval of sin. Turn from the promotion of behaviors that lead to destruction. Reaffirm the great Lutheran heritage of allegiance to the truth and authority of Scripture. Turn back from distorting the grace of God into sensuality. Rejoice in the pardon of the cross of Christ and its power to transform left and right wing sinners.
Monday, August 17, 2009
The Hound of Heaven
Hear this from Francis Thompson, the suicidal, opium-addicted, self-destructive charity case of a London prostitute:
- I fled Him, down the nights and down the days;
- I fled Him, down the arches of the years;
- I fled Him, down the labyrinthine ways
- Of my own mind; and in the mist of tears
- I hid from Him, and under running laughter.
- Up vistaed hopes I sped;
- And shot, precipitated,
- Adown Titanic glooms of chasmèd fears,
- From those strong Feet that followed, followed after.
- But with unhurrying chase,
- And unperturbèd pace,
- Deliberate speed, majestic instancy,
- They beat -- and a voice beat
- More instant than the Feet --
- "All things betray thee, who betrayest Me."
- I pleaded, outlaw-wise,
- By many a hearted casement, curtained red,
- Trellised with intertwining charities;
- (For, though I knew His love Who followèd,
- Yet was I sore adread
- Lest, having Him, I must have naught beside.)
- But, if one little casement parted wide,
- The gust of his approach would clash it to :
- Fear wist not to evade, as Love wist to pursue.
- Across the margent of the world I fled,
- And troubled the gold gateways of the stars,
- Smiting for shelter on their clangèd bars ;
- Fretted to dulcet jars
- And silvern chatter the pale ports o' the moon.
- I said to Dawn : Be sudden -- to Eve : Be soon ;
- With thy young skiey blossoms heap me over
- From this tremendous Lover--
- Float thy vague veil about me, lest He see !
- I tempted all His servitors, but to find
- My own betrayal in their constancy,
- In faith to Him their fickleness to me,
- Their traitorous trueness, and their loyal deceit.
- To all swift things for swiftness did I sue ;
- Clung to the whistling mane of every wind.
- But whether they swept, smoothly fleet,
- The long savannahs of the blue ;
- Or whether, Thunder-driven,
- They clanged his chariot 'thwart a heaven,
- Plashy with flying lightnings round the spurn o' their feet :--
- Fear wist not to evade as Love wist to pursue.
- Still with unhurrying chase,
- And unperturbèd pace,
- Deliberate speed, majestic instancy,
- Came on the following Feet,
- And a Voice above their beat--
- "Naught shelters thee, who wilt not shelter Me."
- I sought no more that after which I strayed,
- In face of man or maid ;
- But still within the little children's eyes
- Seems something, something that replies,
- They at least are for me, surely for me !
- I turned me to them very wistfully ;
- But just as their young eyes grew sudden fair
- With dawning answers there,
- Their angel plucked them from me by the hair.
- "Come then, ye other children, Nature's -- share
- With me" (said I) "your delicate fellowship ;
- Let me greet you lip to lip,
- Let me twine with you caresses,
- Wantoning
- With our Lady-Mother's vagrant tresses,
- Banqueting
- With her in her wind-walled palace,
- Underneath her azured daïs,
- Quaffing, as your taintless way is,
- From a chalice
- Lucent-weeping out of the dayspring."
- So it was done :
- I in their delicate fellowship was one --
- Drew the bolt of Nature's secrecies.
- I knew all the swift importings
- On the wilful face of skies ;
- I knew how the clouds arise
- Spumèd of the wild sea-snortings ;
- All that's born or dies
- Rose and drooped with ; made them shapers
- Of mine own moods, or wailful or divine ;
- With them joyed and was bereaven.
- I was heavy with the even,
- When she lit her glimmering tapers
- Round the day's dead sanctities.
- I laughed in the morning's eyes.
- I triumphed and I saddened with all weather,
- Heaven and I wept together,
- And its sweet tears were salt with mortal mine ;
- Against the red throb of its sunset-heart
- I laid my own to beat,
- And share commingling heat ;
- But not by that, by that, was eased my human smart.
- In vain my tears were wet on Heaven's grey cheek.
- For ah ! we know not what each other says,
- These things and I ; in sound I speak--
- Their sound is but their stir, they speak by silences.
- Nature, poor stepdame, cannot slake my drouth ;
- Let her, if she would owe me,
- Drop yon blue bosom-veil of sky, and show me
- The breasts o' her tenderness ;
- Never did any milk of hers once bless
- My thirsting mouth.
- Nigh and nigh draws the chase,
- With unperturbèd pace,
- Deliberate speed, majestic instancy ;
- And past those noisèd Feet
- A Voice comes yet more fleet --
- "Lo ! naught contents thee, who content'st not Me."
- Naked I wait thy Love's uplifted stroke !
- My harness piece by piece Thou hast hewn from me,
- And smitten me to my knee ;
- I am defenceless utterly.
- I slept, methinks, and woke,
- And, slowly gazing, find me stripped in sleep.
- In the rash lustihead of my young powers,
- I shook the pillaring hours
- And pulled my life upon me ; grimed with smears,
- I stand amid the dust o' the mounded years --
- My mangled youth lies dead beneath the heap.
- My days have crackled and gone up in smoke,
- Have puffed and burst as sun-starts on a stream.
- Yea, faileth now even dream
- The dreamer, and the lute the lutanist ;
- Even the linked fantasies, in whose blossomy twist
- I swung the earth a trinket at my wrist,
- Are yielding ; cords of all too weak account
- For earth with heavy griefs so overplussed.
- Ah ! is Thy love indeed
- A weed, albeit an amaranthine weed,
- Suffering no flowers except its own to mount ?
- Ah ! must --
- Designer infinite !--
- Ah ! must Thou char the wood ere Thou canst limn with it ?
- My freshness spent its wavering shower i' the dust ;
- And now my heart is as a broken fount,
- Wherein tear-drippings stagnate, spilt down ever
- From the dank thoughts that shiver
- Upon the sighful branches of my mind.
- Such is ; what is to be ?
- The pulp so bitter, how shall taste the rind ?
- I dimly guess what Time in mists confounds ;
- Yet ever and anon a trumpet sounds
- From the hid battlements of Eternity ;
- Those shaken mists a space unsettle, then
- Round the half-glimpsed turrets slowly wash again.
- But not ere him who summoneth
- I first have seen, enwound
- With glooming robes purpureal, cypress-crowned ;
- His name I know, and what his trumpet saith.
- Whether man's heart or life it be which yields
- Thee harvest, must Thy harvest-fields
- Be dunged with rotten death ?
- Now of that long pursuit
- Comes on at hand the bruit ;
- That Voice is round me like a bursting sea :
- "And is thy earth so marred,
- Shattered in shard on shard ?
- Lo, all things fly thee, for thou fliest me !
- "Strange, piteous, futile thing !
- Wherefore should any set thee love apart ?
- Seeing none but I makes much of naught" (He said),
- "And human love needs human meriting :
- How hast thou merited --
- Of all man's clotted clay the dingiest clot ?
- Alack, thou knowest not
- How little worthy of any love thou art !
- Whom wilt thou find to love ignoble thee,
- Save Me, save only Me ?
- All which I took from thee I did but take,
- Not for thy harms,
- But just that thou might'st seek it in My arms.
- All which thy child's mistake
- Fancies as lost, I have stored for thee at home :
- Rise, clasp My hand, and come !"
- Halts by me that footfall :
- Is my gloom, after all,
- Shade of His hand, outstretched caressingly ?
- "Ah, fondest, blindest, weakest,
- I am He Whom thou seekest !
- Thou dravest love from thee, who dravest me."
Sunday, August 2, 2009
Lewis and Keller
Some people have called Tim Keller a C.S. Lewis for the 21st century. N.T. Wright is apparently also in the running. I disagree on both counts. They both need to write paradigm-shifting fiction before they have a shot, and neither have come within a mile or kilometer of it, respectively.
But here is one considerable tie between Keller and Lewis: critique of religion and irreligion in favor of the gospel. Keller's book The Prodigal God carries the theme. Keller's basic schema is this: my identity is in something religious that I do, or my identity is in something non-religious (or, more likely, or pseudo-religious) that I do, or my identity is lost in Christ. (That is to say, found in Christ.)
In a video Keller references an essay by Lewis called "Three Kinds of Men" that was seminal for his thinking on the topic. Here's the essay in full:
But here is one considerable tie between Keller and Lewis: critique of religion and irreligion in favor of the gospel. Keller's book The Prodigal God carries the theme. Keller's basic schema is this: my identity is in something religious that I do, or my identity is in something non-religious (or, more likely, or pseudo-religious) that I do, or my identity is lost in Christ. (That is to say, found in Christ.)
In a video Keller references an essay by Lewis called "Three Kinds of Men" that was seminal for his thinking on the topic. Here's the essay in full:
Three Kinds of Men
There are three kinds of people in the world. The fist class is of those who live simply for their own sake and pleasure, regarding mand and Nature as so much raw material to be cut up into whatever shape may serve them. In the second class are those who acknowledge some other claim upon them - the will of God, the categorical imperative, or the good of society - and honestly try to pursue their own interests no further than this claim will allow. They try to surrender to the higher claim as much as it demands, like men paying a tax, but hope, like other taxpayers, that what is left over will be enough for them to live on. Their life is divided, like a soldier's or a schoolboy's life, into time "on parade" and "off parade", "in school" and "out of school". But the third class is of those who can say like St Paul that for them "to live is Christ". These people have got rid of the tiresome business of adjusting the rival claims of Self and God by the simple expedient of rejecting the claims of Self altogether. The old egoistic will has been turned round, reconditioned, and made into a new thing. The will of Christ no longer limits theirs; it is theirs. All their time, in belonging to Him, Belongs also to them, for they are His.
And because there are three classes, any merely twofold division of the world into good and bad is disasterous. It overlooks the fact that the members of the second class (to which most of us belong) are always an necessarily unhappy. The tax which moral conscience levies on our desires does not in fact leave us enough to live on. As long as we are in this class we must either feel guilt because we have not paid the tax or penury because we have. The Christian doctrine that there is no "salvation" by works done accouding to the moral law is a fact of daily experience. Back or on we must go. But there is no going on simply by our own efforts. If the new Self, the new Will, does no come at His own good pleasure to be born in us, we cannot produce Him synthetically.
The price of Christ is something, in a way, much easier than moral effort - it is to want Him. It is true that the wanting itself would be beyond our power but for one fact. The world is so built that, to help us desert our own satisfactions, they desert us. War and trouble and funally old age take from us one by one all those things that the natural Self hoped for at its setting out. Begging is our only wisdom, and want in the end makes it easier for us to be beggars. Even on those terms the Mercy will receive us.
And because there are three classes, any merely twofold division of the world into good and bad is disasterous. It overlooks the fact that the members of the second class (to which most of us belong) are always an necessarily unhappy. The tax which moral conscience levies on our desires does not in fact leave us enough to live on. As long as we are in this class we must either feel guilt because we have not paid the tax or penury because we have. The Christian doctrine that there is no "salvation" by works done accouding to the moral law is a fact of daily experience. Back or on we must go. But there is no going on simply by our own efforts. If the new Self, the new Will, does no come at His own good pleasure to be born in us, we cannot produce Him synthetically.
The price of Christ is something, in a way, much easier than moral effort - it is to want Him. It is true that the wanting itself would be beyond our power but for one fact. The world is so built that, to help us desert our own satisfactions, they desert us. War and trouble and funally old age take from us one by one all those things that the natural Self hoped for at its setting out. Begging is our only wisdom, and want in the end makes it easier for us to be beggars. Even on those terms the Mercy will receive us.
Tuesday, June 23, 2009
Guthrie on Hebrews 9:1-10
Brothers: this thought has been of particular help to me as of late. Be 'monotonous' in your love for and pursuit of Jesus.
'Some moderns would look at a passage like Hebrews 9:1-10 and yawn at the sheer monotony. Yet monotony may be a sign of vibrant, pulsating existence that revels in a place, time, and practice of what is right and beautiful. "A child kicks its legs rhythmically through excess, not absence, of life. Because children have abounding vitality, because they are in spirit fierce and free, therefore they want things repeated and unchanged. They always say, 'Do it again,' and the grown-up person does it again until he is nearly dead. For grown-up people are not strong enough to exult in monotony. But perhaps God is strong enough....It is possible that God says every morning, 'Do it again,' to the sun; and every evening, 'Do it again,' to the moon. It may not be automatic necessity that makes all daisies [or dandelions...] alike: it may be that God makes every daisy separately, but has never got tired of making them. It may be that He has the eternal appetite of infancy; for we have sinned and grown old, and our Father is younger than we" (Chesterton). The turn of the seasons, the beating of a heart, the revolutions of the earth, the year-to-year march through the decades of a committed marriage--all are signs of life that can never be labeled "dull." God seems to like rhythms, and we must join him in the rhythm of holiness: drawing near, living in a "monotonous" submission to his will. Jesus reflected perfectly this type of holiness, a wholeness of life centered on the perfect will of God' (Guthrie 305-6).
'Some moderns would look at a passage like Hebrews 9:1-10 and yawn at the sheer monotony. Yet monotony may be a sign of vibrant, pulsating existence that revels in a place, time, and practice of what is right and beautiful. "A child kicks its legs rhythmically through excess, not absence, of life. Because children have abounding vitality, because they are in spirit fierce and free, therefore they want things repeated and unchanged. They always say, 'Do it again,' and the grown-up person does it again until he is nearly dead. For grown-up people are not strong enough to exult in monotony. But perhaps God is strong enough....It is possible that God says every morning, 'Do it again,' to the sun; and every evening, 'Do it again,' to the moon. It may not be automatic necessity that makes all daisies [or dandelions...] alike: it may be that God makes every daisy separately, but has never got tired of making them. It may be that He has the eternal appetite of infancy; for we have sinned and grown old, and our Father is younger than we" (Chesterton). The turn of the seasons, the beating of a heart, the revolutions of the earth, the year-to-year march through the decades of a committed marriage--all are signs of life that can never be labeled "dull." God seems to like rhythms, and we must join him in the rhythm of holiness: drawing near, living in a "monotonous" submission to his will. Jesus reflected perfectly this type of holiness, a wholeness of life centered on the perfect will of God' (Guthrie 305-6).
Sunday, January 4, 2009
Patience, O Bride
We're supposed to plead for the Kingdom to come--sure. Remember, though, that in praying for Jesus' return we are also (whether consciously or not) asking for the damnation of unbelievers--many of whom have yet to hear a gospel proclamation.
We're quick to pray for Kingdom peace,
For Christ's return, the Marriage Feast,
For God to rule in pow'r and might,
When all rebel'ion 's put to flight;
For wine to flow and songs to sing
In endless praise before the King.
But what, if now, his reign should come?
If earth should cease, it's course full run?
What would the lot of sinners be
Who haven't yet embraced Mercy?
Nothing but pain--the second death;
No joy or peace--tort'rous unrest.
So when we pray, O Church, let's be
More patient to embrace Glory,
And suffer long that sinners may
Rejoice with us on that Last Day.
Then we in One, with one accord,
Will congregate to praise the Lord.
O Father, grant us one more day
To wrest from Satan's grasp the clay
Which you have made and Christ redeemed.
Please stay thy hand--if good it seems.
We're quick to pray for Kingdom peace,
For Christ's return, the Marriage Feast,
For God to rule in pow'r and might,
When all rebel'ion 's put to flight;
For wine to flow and songs to sing
In endless praise before the King.
But what, if now, his reign should come?
If earth should cease, it's course full run?
What would the lot of sinners be
Who haven't yet embraced Mercy?
Nothing but pain--the second death;
No joy or peace--tort'rous unrest.
So when we pray, O Church, let's be
More patient to embrace Glory,
And suffer long that sinners may
Rejoice with us on that Last Day.
Then we in One, with one accord,
Will congregate to praise the Lord.
O Father, grant us one more day
To wrest from Satan's grasp the clay
Which you have made and Christ redeemed.
Please stay thy hand--if good it seems.
Saturday, January 3, 2009
Monday, December 15, 2008
Thoughts
The only rule of faith therefore to every Christian, is the Doctrine of Christ; and that doctrine as applied to him by his own understanding. In which matter, to preserve his understanding from erring, he is obliged indeed, at his utmost peril, to lay aside all Vice and all Prejudice and to make use of the best assistances he can procure: But after he has done all that can be done, he must of necessity at last understand with his own understanding, and believe with his own, and not another[’]s faith. For (whatever has sometimes been absurdly pretended to the contrary,) ‘tis evidently as impossible in Nature, that in these things any person should submit himself to another, as that one man should see or taste, should live or breathe for another.
- Samuel Clarke, Scripture-Doctrine, ii
N. T. Wright argues that ultimate vindication (i.e. salvation) is the result not of a creature's confession ('Jesus, you are Lord') or a divine declaration at the time of said confession (i.e. 'You are justified') but rather on the basis of the life lived [Note: 'merely' is an important qualifier]. In less colorful terms and with far-less an understanding of the holistic message of Scripture, I've found myself gravitating to this position over the past three years. The Text appears to place far more emphasis on the role of works within the Covenant community than it seems Protestants have been historically willing to grant. I don't espouse the New Perspective in its entirety, but (at the very least) I think there are elements which we would do well to consider. Here are a few of my thoughts; I invite criticism.
First. To ask 'What is the role of works within a New Covenant context?' is to begin at the wrong place. We must, in my estimation, begin with the more foundational question: 'What was the role of works in the Old Covenant?' Maybe we have neglected this question because of Paul's language against 'works of the law', particularly in Romans. Certainly Paul argues strongly and often against a works-based, outwardly-ritualistic-but-inwardly-corrupt 'righteousness'. But, might we have merely misunderstood why Paul hammers Second-Temple Judaism? Paul's contention seems to lie not with the Divine intent of the law but with what the Jews had done with the law (i.e. made it into the 'works-based' system referred to above). Initial justification has always been by faith. Romans 4 is clear on this point. Abraham, apart from the works of the law, is declared righteous. So, if entrance into the Covenant community was based on faith and not doing the law, what is the actual point of doing the law? Wright would answer that the law was done not to get into the covenant but to maintain one's status within the Covenant. Again, Paul isn't trashing the intent of the law, he's bucking what the Jews had made the law to be--namely prior and indifferent to faith. Thus, the Pharisees fulfilled the letter but not the spirit of the law, and so invalidated their own religion. Let's shift the paradigm to a New Covenant context: 1) The basis for entrance into a Covenant relationship with God: faith in the promises of God (Eph. 2:8-9); 2) The reason for doing works: to maintain one's covenantal status (1 and 2 Timothy, which we will observe in a second). One might object, 'How is the New better than the Old? What's 'new' about the New?' One immeasurably important detail: the means of fulfilling ‘the faith’ --the Spirit. That's the great promise of the New Covenant. Jesus comes, gives himself as a ransom for his Bride, inaugurates the NC, and gives us the Spirit to empower us to do what, in the flesh, we were formerly incapable of ever accomplishing.
Second. Studying through portions of 1 and 2 Timothy has helped me put several pieces of this puzzle together. I don’t want to do (or, it would be more honest to say I’m incapable of doing) a thorough biblical theology of the 2 epistles—but here are a few themes for consideration.
1. In 1 and 2 Timothy, Paul presents ‘the faith’ as something which (though certainly apprehended at one point).
2. Paul demonstrates by way of personal examples that some have forsaken the faith
My question/proposition is: should we view works as did Old Covenant believers and as Paul at least hints at in 1 and 2 Timothy--namely that salvation is a process in which ultimate vindication will be prescribed on the basis of the life [of faith] lived and not merely a creature's initial confession or the Divine's preliminary pronouncement?
- Samuel Clarke, Scripture-Doctrine, ii
N. T. Wright argues that ultimate vindication (i.e. salvation) is the result not of a creature's confession ('Jesus, you are Lord') or a divine declaration at the time of said confession (i.e. 'You are justified') but rather on the basis of the life lived [Note: 'merely' is an important qualifier]. In less colorful terms and with far-less an understanding of the holistic message of Scripture, I've found myself gravitating to this position over the past three years. The Text appears to place far more emphasis on the role of works within the Covenant community than it seems Protestants have been historically willing to grant. I don't espouse the New Perspective in its entirety, but (at the very least) I think there are elements which we would do well to consider. Here are a few of my thoughts; I invite criticism.
First. To ask 'What is the role of works within a New Covenant context?' is to begin at the wrong place. We must, in my estimation, begin with the more foundational question: 'What was the role of works in the Old Covenant?' Maybe we have neglected this question because of Paul's language against 'works of the law', particularly in Romans. Certainly Paul argues strongly and often against a works-based, outwardly-ritualistic-but-inwardly-corrupt 'righteousness'. But, might we have merely misunderstood why Paul hammers Second-Temple Judaism? Paul's contention seems to lie not with the Divine intent of the law but with what the Jews had done with the law (i.e. made it into the 'works-based' system referred to above). Initial justification has always been by faith. Romans 4 is clear on this point. Abraham, apart from the works of the law, is declared righteous. So, if entrance into the Covenant community was based on faith and not doing the law, what is the actual point of doing the law? Wright would answer that the law was done not to get into the covenant but to maintain one's status within the Covenant. Again, Paul isn't trashing the intent of the law, he's bucking what the Jews had made the law to be--namely prior and indifferent to faith. Thus, the Pharisees fulfilled the letter but not the spirit of the law, and so invalidated their own religion. Let's shift the paradigm to a New Covenant context: 1) The basis for entrance into a Covenant relationship with God: faith in the promises of God (Eph. 2:8-9); 2) The reason for doing works: to maintain one's covenantal status (1 and 2 Timothy, which we will observe in a second). One might object, 'How is the New better than the Old? What's 'new' about the New?' One immeasurably important detail: the means of fulfilling ‘the faith’ --the Spirit. That's the great promise of the New Covenant. Jesus comes, gives himself as a ransom for his Bride, inaugurates the NC, and gives us the Spirit to empower us to do what, in the flesh, we were formerly incapable of ever accomplishing.
Second. Studying through portions of 1 and 2 Timothy has helped me put several pieces of this puzzle together. I don’t want to do (or, it would be more honest to say I’m incapable of doing) a thorough biblical theology of the 2 epistles—but here are a few themes for consideration.
1. In 1 and 2 Timothy, Paul presents ‘the faith’ as something which (though certainly apprehended at one point).
- 1:18-19a: '[By following the instructions I have given to you] you may fight the good faith, holding on to faith and a good conscience.'
- 2:15: 'Women will be saved through [the Child's birth]--if they continue in faith, love, and holiness with propriety.'
- 4:16: 'Watch your life and doctrine closely. Persevere in them, because if you do, you will save both yourself and your hearers.'
- 5:8: 'If anyone does not provide for his relatives, and especially for his immediate family, he has the faith and is worse than an unbeliever.'
- 6:12: 'Fight the good fight of the faith. Take hold of the eternal life to which you were called when you made your good confession..."
- 2 Tim 2:12-13: 'If we endure, we will also reign with him. If we disown him, he will disown us; if we are faithless, he will remain faithful, for he cannot disown himself" [I take 'he will remain faithful' to be referring to God's faithfulness in the act of disowning those who are faithless].'
2. Paul demonstrates by way of personal examples that some have forsaken the faith
- 1:19b-20: 'Some...have shipwrecked their faith. Among them are Hymenaeus and Alexander, whom I have handed over to Satan to be taught not to blaspheme.'
- 4:1-2: 'The Spirit clearly says that in later times some will abandon the faith and follow deceiving spirits and things taught by demons.'
- 5:15: 'Some have in fact already turned away to follow Satan'
- In 2 Timothy, Paul refers to himself frequently as 'being deserted', meaning that some were with him (presumably 'in the faith' as in 1 Tim) who forsook him for the love of the world (as in 4:10).
My question/proposition is: should we view works as did Old Covenant believers and as Paul at least hints at in 1 and 2 Timothy--namely that salvation is a process in which ultimate vindication will be prescribed on the basis of the life [of faith] lived and not merely a creature's initial confession or the Divine's preliminary pronouncement?
Monday, November 3, 2008
Random thought...
Being serious is embarrassing. Speakers try to tell jokes to break the seriousness of their message. Speakers try to reprimand their audiences lightly and jocularly. Friends hint and peck around confrontation of each other instead of bluntly stating their case.
One of the reasons suffering is good is that during or after deep, distressing mental or physical anguish, we lose our embarrassment of being serious with other people.
One of the reasons suffering is good is that during or after deep, distressing mental or physical anguish, we lose our embarrassment of being serious with other people.
Sunday, October 19, 2008
Great blog
This guy is a M. Div. student from Southern who is just about to start in their PhD program. I spoke with him a little regarding a paper I am doing for Baptist History, and he's a real cool guy. And he has a great blog.
http://dannymcdonald.wordpress.com/
http://dannymcdonald.wordpress.com/
Wednesday, October 15, 2008
Isa 64
Our God, we know you came
And left us not the same
But hope from silence drips
As day by evening slips
Oh, let us hear our name
From your lips
The mountains shook with fear
Words thundered from the seer
But quiet now the song
From shadows growing long
We want to you be near
And belong
You are still our father
Still of clay the Potter
Don't let us fall to drown
Replace our filthy gown
Love your rebel daughter
And come down
And left us not the same
But hope from silence drips
As day by evening slips
Oh, let us hear our name
From your lips
The mountains shook with fear
Words thundered from the seer
But quiet now the song
From shadows growing long
We want to you be near
And belong
You are still our father
Still of clay the Potter
Don't let us fall to drown
Replace our filthy gown
Love your rebel daughter
And come down
Saturday, October 11, 2008
Poetry
Poetry seems to be a bit of a theme right now for us. Jon's writing a song, and recording it with a computer microphone until further notice, and Wes is writing a narrative poem and then little things like this.
Let's be men and post some more poetry. As Jon said, "It's a good spiritual exercise." I agree. Ehrman taught me this: the only way we understand words is by putting words into other words. When we can take out an abstract idea out of its old words and squish it into new words so that it doesn't lose its shape, we have learned the idea. Poetry does that.
Let's be men and post some more poetry. As Jon said, "It's a good spiritual exercise." I agree. Ehrman taught me this: the only way we understand words is by putting words into other words. When we can take out an abstract idea out of its old words and squish it into new words so that it doesn't lose its shape, we have learned the idea. Poetry does that.
Thursday, October 9, 2008
1 Timothy 1:15-16
Here is a trustworthy saying that deserves full acceptance: Christ Jesus came into the world to save sinners—of whom I am the worst. But for that very reason I was shown mercy so that in me, the worst of sinners, Christ Jesus might display his unlimited patience as an example for those who would believe on him and receive eternal life.
The paradox of sin is this:
It kills and damns our souls.
Yet once in Christ--the debt erased--
God works it for his Fold.
The paradox of sin is this:
It kills and damns our souls.
Yet once in Christ--the debt erased--
God works it for his Fold.
Wednesday, August 20, 2008
Work
My body hates work. I hate work. If I could, I believe I would avoid work for the rest of my life. Work is hard - it takes energy of body and mind and leaves us tired. In my mind, I often contrast work with pleasure; and I tell myself that after a certain amount of work I deserve pleasure.
Kinds of work I hate
Why I hate work
Is anyone else out there sinning by neglecting work? Labor in prayer, labor in body, labor in discipline? Does anyone else hear the "vanity" recitations of Ecclesiastes and get discouraged?
But brothers, out labor is not in vain. It would be so had we not a great Lord who does not forget our labor.
"For God is not unjust so as to forget your work..." Heb 6.10
Our lot while we linger here is work. We have much to do. Yet we are slow, sluggish, and shirking of our work. May we be convicted of the Spirit and labor hard at our work.
I don't know what is so godly about hard work, but something about it is. Conversely, laziness is very wicked. I'll meditate on this, but as a conviction of the Spirit just today on my life, I wanted to lay this charge to you all as well.
Kinds of work I hate
- Fighting sin
This is work - really hard work. If you disagree, you don't fight sin. - Discipline
Waking up in the morning, exercising when I don't want to, turning off the TV, getting off the computer when wasting time, stopping wasting time of any kind, working while I am at my job are all hard work. - Studying
Why I hate work
- It takes time.
This is especially true of studying. I see the massive amount of work between me and someone who has been working for years, and don't want to begin. - It is discouraging.
Before I start work of any kind, I usually have to beat discouragement. Going to exercise again.... again - I just hate that feeling of repetition and "ought." - It makes me feel bad when I don't do it.
Looking at a messy room is depressing.
Is anyone else out there sinning by neglecting work? Labor in prayer, labor in body, labor in discipline? Does anyone else hear the "vanity" recitations of Ecclesiastes and get discouraged?
But brothers, out labor is not in vain. It would be so had we not a great Lord who does not forget our labor.
"For God is not unjust so as to forget your work..." Heb 6.10
Our lot while we linger here is work. We have much to do. Yet we are slow, sluggish, and shirking of our work. May we be convicted of the Spirit and labor hard at our work.
I don't know what is so godly about hard work, but something about it is. Conversely, laziness is very wicked. I'll meditate on this, but as a conviction of the Spirit just today on my life, I wanted to lay this charge to you all as well.
Sunday, July 20, 2008
Word of the ten days
Reductionism
- The practice of reducing an idea, theory, or system down to its sine qua non.
- In a destructive way, reductionism removes so much that it erodes the original until the original lacks the qualities that it held as a whole.
- Applied to systematic theology, reductionism removes or overlooks the whole picture in favor of seeing a part. E.g. considering only passages that support one's own position and neglecting conflicting passages.
Mark Driscoll calls reductionism the largest producer of aberrant doctrine.
Thursday, July 10, 2008
Word of the week
Continuing now with a theme of literary considerations surrounding interpreting the Bible, we come to an "-ism" we must grapple with.
Deconstructionism
Deconstructionism
- Refers to the "deconstruction" of an author's original meaning. Authorial intent (whether in a biblical passage or not) is more or less lost immediately after text is recorded, thus making impossible the hope of "objective interpretation."
- At least four factors contribute to the "deconstruction" (I think of it using erosion - certain powers gradually washing away the "river bank" of an author's intention). 1) Author forgetfulness or change in position. A given author cannot remember what he or she meant precisely by each statement he or she made in the past, thus authorial intent is lost. Or, an author may later shift in ideology and no longer support his or her original position and bend his or her own words to accomodate the updated position. (This first factor only applies to texts with authors who are still alive, obviously) 2) The mutability of words. Words change meaning constantly. Take the term "complacency." This term was used in the 18th century to describe William Wilberforce; however, it refered to his kindness and goodness instead of a lack of conviction, as it would be used today. Thus, authorial intent is lost to the evolution of language. 3) Reader bias. All readers purposefully (no matter how rigorously they pursue "objectivity") project their own beliefs and mental habits on a text. Thus authorial intent is lost to reader intent. 4) Words are only symbolically meaningful; they have no intrinsic meaning. The only way a reader can understand a set of spoken or written words is to put those words in other words - words that they know. This becomes unmistakably clear in translation work, but holds even within a given language. Words refer to other words, some of which have attached concrete meanings. These relationships and mental attachments differ from person to person so that no two people use a word in exactly the same way. Thus authorial intent is lost to differing apprehensions of the language tool.
- Deconstruction says, at bottom, that one can only have a small degree of certainty regarding a given text or spoken word. It applies to everyday conversation, but to a lesser degree than to ancient documents. This pertains directly to biblical exegesis; time has compounded the affect of the four factors given in point #2.
Thursday, July 3, 2008
Word (theological term) of the Week
Redaction Criticism
- The critical study of how biblical authors/editors preserved and/or altered the text through history to present the text as we have it today.
- This study can apply to any ancient document that was copied or transmitted orally.
- This study has liberal connotations. When applied to a study of the gospels it assumes a few things: 1) Markan priority (thus the other gospelers were redacting what Mark wrote), 2) unhistorical accounts (anything supernatural carries no historicity; therefore accounts of anything supernatural were either made up by the redactor, or the redactor was convinced of it by people around him/her), 3) Redaction (the biblical texts were in fact changed as they progressed toward canonization)
Thursday, June 26, 2008
Word of the week
Aetiology (ee-tee-OL-uh-jee)
- : the cause or causes of a disease or abnormal condition
- : a branch of medical science dealing with the causes and origin of diseases
- : The study of origins - non-philological etymology.
I came across this in a Grace Theological article discussing the origins of the ancient concept of the snake as a source of dark wisdom. The article spoke of the aetiology of the snake idea.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)